Score | Criteria |
---|---|
5 | An extremely significant proposal, which is expected to obtain exceptional view or new perspectives, develop other experimental methods. |
4 | A significant proposal, which is expected to obtain excellent view or develop other effective experimental methods (or introduce/spread). |
3 | An appropriate proposal, which is expected to have valuable results. |
2 | A proposal which is not worth performing. |
1 | A proposal with no value. |
Score | (a) A proposal with new synchrotron radiation techniques | (b) A proposal with established synchrotron radiation techniques |
---|---|---|
5 | It is well considered and most likely to obtain expected results. | |
4 | It is generally considered and requires further consideration for details. | It is well considered and most likely to obtain expected results. |
3 | It requires further consideration including main parts. | It is generally considered and requires further consideration for details. |
2 | It lacks consideration, and it is highly likely that they can not obtain expected results. | It requires further consideration including main parts. |
1 | It lacks consideration, and it is highly likely that they can not obtain expected results. |
Score | Criteria |
---|---|
5 | An especially outstanding group which is able to sort out troubles by themselves and carry out the experiments. |
4 | An excellent group which is able to deal with troubles somehow by themselves and carry out the experiments. |
3 | A group which can carry out the experiments if the trouble doesn't happen. |
2 | A group which needs some help from PF staff to carry out the experiments. |
1 | A group which needs a great amount of help from PF staff to carry out the experiments. |
Note: The criteria for review (in Japanese) is a document approved by the PF-PAC. The English version of the criteria (this document) was translated into English based on the Japanese version by the PF-PAC secretariat.
Last modified: 2023-09-25 (English version)